|
|
|
DRAFT
Procedures for Developing
|
TIMETABLE FOR RESEARCH PROJECT DEVELOPMENT
I. College Research Project (Hatch, McIntire-Stennis, Animal Health, and State)
Planning and research project development should begin six months prior to the desired starting date. The following is the recommended schedule for the steps in the process. |
II. Regional Research Project
| Planning and research project development should begin 12 months prior to the desired
starting date. The following is the recommended timetable for the steps in the process. Activity Time Prior to Project Starting Date |
PROCEDURES FOR PREPARING IAES RESEARCH PROJECTS
These procedures are provided as a guide for developing a research project in the
Idaho Agricultural Experiment Station.
Background
All faculty members holding research appointments in the Idaho Agricultural Experiment Station (IAES) are required to have an active, approved research project that reflects their major research emphasis. The official, approved research project is the vehicle through which state funds (Idaho's Ag Research appropriation) and federal funds [the Hatch Act appropriation administered by the Cooperative State Research, Education and Extension Service (CSREES), USDA] can be allocated to support a research activity (faculty and support personnel salaries, travel, operational, and equipment funds).
All projects in the IAES regardless of whether they are categorized as "State" projects, "Hatch" projects, or "Regional" projects must be prepared and submitted as complete, in depth research proposals according to the guidelines given below which detail the required format for the project, the internal and external peer review procedure, and the required forms that must accompany the project proposal. IAES projects should be prepared with the level of professionalism and detail appropriate for a competitive grant proposal to be submitted to a major federal agency (e.g., USDA, NSF, NIH, etc.) and, accordingly, should include the precise research plan and timetable to be followed for the proposed research activity. Generally, IAES projects detail a 3 to 5 year research plan.
Faculty members holding appointments in the IAES are responsible for knowing when their IAES projects are scheduled to terminate and should initiate the preparation of their new IAES project well in advance of the date that their existing project is scheduled to terminate (see Timetable for Research Project Development). Ideally, a "new" IAES project should have received the necessary approvals prior to the termination date of the "old"/previous project. In general, new faculty members in the college who have research appointments should prepare and submit an IAES project not later than 6 months after joining the University of Idaho.
For information, brief descriptions of the three categories of IAES research projects are:
Sequence for Project Preparation, Review and Approval
Planning for a project should begin six to twelve months prior to the desired starting date. The starting date for Hatch projects is July 1 and October 1 for Regional Hatch projects. The procedure for develop a research project involves the following important sequential steps.
8. Transmit project. The project leader transmits the final project outline along with the appropriate forms and the reviews of the project to the department head/unit administrator. The unit administrator reviews the project content and the accompanying forms to assure that they have been properly prepared. The unit administrator signs form AD-416 and transmits the project outline, the signature AD-416, AD-417, CSREES-662 and other relevant attachments (documentation of external peer review, MUA for recombinant DNA research, etc.) to the IAES director.
9. Approval. Upon approval by the IAES director, a work unit/project number is assigned and the project and accompanying materials are submitted to USDA/Current Research Information System (CRIS) for approval by USDA/CSREES, Washington D.C. When the IAES director receives official notice that the project has been approved, the IAES office notifies the appropriate department(s)/administrative unit(s), Ag Administrative Services, University Budget Office, and project leader. The director, in consultation with the department head/unit administrator, can allocate/redirect existing USDA/CSREES Hatch and regional research formula funds and/or state funds appropriated for agricultural research to help support the research activity. [All should be aware that when a new project is approved, no new resources flow into the IAES, i.e., no new USDA/CSREES formula funds or State funds are realized. Accordingly, the availability of funds to support both new and existing research projects is restricted both at the IAES and departmental levels. Faculty and unit administrators should understand these funding limitations.]
10. Reporting. The AD-421 Progress Report is used for reporting annual progress on active research projects and summary reports for terminated (completed) projects. On a calendar year basis these reports are requested via the departmental offices. Final summary reports for terminated grants are due within 90 days following the termination date. Attached are instructions for the completion and an example of an AD-421.
APPENDIX A
ESSENTIALS OF A PROJECT OUTLINE
IAES project outlines should contain the sections given below:
TITLE: A brief, clear, specific designation of the subject of the research. The title used by itself, should reflect the objective(s) and scope of the project. The title must be limited to 100 spaces. {If the IAES project is to contribute to an approved Regional Research Project (RRP), the project title must be identical to that of the regional project. In this case, a specific subtitle may be appropriate to accurately reflect the IAES research that will contribute to the regional research.}
JUSTIFICATION: Present (1) the importance of the problem to agriculture, rural life, and general public of Idaho, the region or the country; (2) reasons for doing the work [such as the needs the project will fill] and doing it at this time; and (3) ways in which public welfare and/or scientific knowledge will be advanced. An estimate of the monetary value of the crop or industry and the possible returns upon successful accomplishment of the objectives may be included. One or two references may be used to document statements, but the review of literature belongs in the next section.
PREVIOUS WORK AND PRESENT OUTLOOK: A brief summary covering pertinent research on the problem (citing only the more important of the recent publications), the status of current research, and the additional information needed and how this project is expected to contribute to this need. The nature of the project and its objectives will obviously determine the ease of predicting success, but where feasible it will be appropriate to indicate the likelihood of achieving the objectives in a specified length of time. This section should indicate (1) questions that have not been answered by research and (2) how the proposed research will fill the gaps.
OBJECTIVES: A concise, clear, complete, and logically arranged and numbered series of statements defining the specific objectives of the project. {If the IAES project is to contribute to an approved RRP, the objectives of the project must be the identical to those of the regional project (a contributing IAES research project will usually address several, but not all, of the objectives of a regional project). For regional IAES projects, it is usually appropriate to include sub-objectives under the regional project objectives that reflect the specific focus of the IAES contribution to the regional research effort.}
PROCEDURE: There should be a numbered procedure statement to correspond with each numbered objective. These statements should outline the essential working plans and methods that will be employed in attaining each objective. Phases of the work to be undertaken currently should be designated. Location of the work and the facilities and equipment needed and available should be indicated. The location of the work, equipment available, and additional equipment needed should be indicated. The procedure statement should show that the research needs and plans have been considered carefully and the proposed work has the potential of providing data and information that which will permit accomplishing the objectives. Cooperation with other departments and other colleges is encouraged. Division of effort and coordination should be clearly stated.
Experimental designs should be such as to maximize efficiency of the research effort and to provide data suitable for statistical analysis. While the details of the kind of experimental design to be used and the number of replications will generally not be specified, it should be understood that due consideration has been given to the levels of experiment error to be anticipated and the levels of precision required for the results to be useful.
Consideration should be given to the eventual method of "publication". Plans should be made for proper collection and recording of data, including photographs or video pictures, if appropriate.
PROBABLE DURATION: Estimate the maximum time (not to exceed 5 years) likely to be required to complete the project and publish the results. Generally, IAES projects outline a 3 to 5 year research plan. When an IAES project contributes to a Regional Research Project, it must terminate the same date that the regional project terminates. Whenever a significant change in the objectives of a project is warranted/advisable, a new or revised project outline should be prepared and submitted for approval. A major change in procedure might also necessitate revision of the project outline.
SUPPORT: List the total scientist-years (SY), professional-years (PY), and technical-years (TY) committed to or proposed for the project. Definitions of these personnel resource categories are given below:
PERSONNEL: List the leader or leaders and other technical workers assigned to the project.
ADVISORY COMMITTEE: An advisory committee is optional. It may be used if desired by the department or project leaders.
INSTITUTIONAL UNITS INVOLVED: Display each subject-matter unit in the IAES and any other units of the university contributing essential services or facilities to the research project. The responsibilities of each should be indicated. If there is an advisory, coordinating, or directing committee for the project, the official title of the committee should be listed.
COOPERATION: If appropriate include a statement listing the USDA or other experiment stations, institutions, or agencies expected to cooperate formally or informally on the project. If the project is part of a regional project, list the Regional Research Project Number.
APPENDIX B
FORMAT FOR ADDENDUM TO
REGIONAL RESEARCH PROJECT OUTLINE
Addendum to (Regional Project Number) regional project covering research at (Institution).
TITLE: Identical to regional project.
OBJECTIVES: Identical to regional project. Include only those objectives to be
undertaken by the participating State, agency, or institution.
PROCEDURES: The working plans and methods to be used by the participant
in
attaining each of the stated objectives. A procedure statement
should be included for each objective and should relate to the
procedures described in the regional project outline.
PROJECT LEADERS: List all principal investigators showing the area of specialization.
RESOURCES: State the annual, SY, PY, TY commitment for each contribution.
SIGNATURES:
_____________________________________________________________________________
(Name of Director, Petitioning Station, Agency, or Institution)
Date
_____________________________________________________________________________
(Name of Administrative Advisor for Regional Project)
Date
_____________________________________________________________________________
Administrator, CSREES
Date
APPENDIX C
GUIDELINES FOR
REVIEWING IAES RESEARCH PROJECTS/PROPOSALS
The following questions are used as guidelines for peer reviewers of IAES research projects:
IDAHO AGRICULTURAL EXPERIMENT STATION
Project Proposal Review
| A Prospectus |
B Project Outline |
|
1. Relevance to research priorities and mission of the department(s) |
__________ | __________ |
| 2. Probability of practical benefits | __________ | __________ |
| 3. Probability of contribution to basic knowledge | __________ | __________ |
| 4. Personnel available and qualified to do proposed work | __________ |
__________ |
| 5. Provisions for cooperative effort | __________ | __________ |
| 6. Probability that objectives will be reached in proposed duration | __________ |
__________ |
| 7. Overall scientific and technological quality | __________ _________ |
__________ |
---------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------
*Rating Scale: 1. Unsatisfactory, 2. Marginal, 3. Good, 4. Very Good, 5. Outstanding
---------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------
A. I have reviewed the Prospectus and rated
______________________________
it in Column A.
Reviewer
Date
Prospectus Approved _______________________________
Department Head Date
---------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------
B. I have reviewed the Project Outline and
_______________________________
rated it in Column B.
Reviewer
Date
Project Outline and
Supporting Documents
Approved
___________________________
________________________
Department Head Date
IAES Director
Date
APPENDIX D
CHECKLIST FOR SUBMISSION OF A
RESEARCH PROJECT
Title:__________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________
New Replacement for # __________
YES NO
1. Information has been obtained through the Current
[ ]
[ ]
Research Information System (CRIS).
2. Project prospectus has been reviewed by 2 or 3 peer
[ ]
[ ]
reviewers, unit leader(s), and IAES director if a new
project and/or new direction of research.
3. Project development meeting was held with appropriate
[ ]
[ ]
scientist(s), unit leader(s), and, if necessary, IAES director.
4. Financial support section has been completed and
[ ]
[ ]
funds are available or arrangements have been made
with the appropriate unit leader(s) and/or IAES director.
5. Facilities for the proposed research are available or
[ ]
[ ]
arrangements have been made with the appropriate
unit leader(s) and/or IAES director.
6. USDA/CSREES forms (AD-416, AD-417, CSREES-662)
[ ]
[ ]
are completed and documentation of appropriate
clearances are enclosed if hazardous materials, animals,
or human subjects are involved.
7. Project proposal conforms to the format outlined in
[ ]
[ ]
"Essentials of a IAES Project."
8. Project proposal has been reviewed by 2 or 3 peer
[ ]
[ ]
reviewers and their reports are enclosed.
9. Project worksheet has been completed and is enclosed. [ ] [ ]
10. Signature sheet has been completed and is enclosed. [ ] [ ]
NOTE: Submit project to the IAES office when all the appropriate items are completed.
APPENDIX E
INFORMATION
RETRIEVAL FROM USDAs
CURRENT RESEARCH INFORMATION SYSTEM
Introduction to CRIS Systems
All research sponsored or conducted by the USDA is required to be documented in CRIS. Cooperating non-Federal institutions voluntarily report all non-Federal research projects as well. CRIS is the Cooperative State Research, Education and Extension Service automated computer-based documentation and reporting system to ongoing agricultural, food and nutrition, and forestry research. CRIS is designed to provide ready access to information about research conducted primarily within the USDA/state agricultural research system.
CRIS contains over 30,000 descriptions of current, publicly supported agricultural and forestry research projects of the USDA agencies, the State Agricultural Experiment Stations, the state university land-grant system, and other cooperating state institutions. Approximately 4,000 new project descriptions and about 20,000 progress and publication reports updating existing projects are entered in CRIS annually. The database is updated weekly.
USDA research agencies, state research institutions, and scientists use CRIS technical data to help prevent duplication, access to up-to-date information in their areas of expertise, make contacts with other scientists doing similar research, and answer Congressional and other legislative requests. The technical database is available for on-line access via the Internet and through Dialog Information Services.
Access to CRIS via INTERNET
INTERNET Access
CRIS database CRISTEL can be accessed by using a WWW browser (e.g., Mosaic or Netscape).
URL addresses for WWW access include:
http://cristel.nal.usda.gov.8080
Another useful WWW site is at http://cos.gdb.org (The Community of Science). This site provides access to the CRIS file as well as several other science- related databases. (Access to some databases requires a subscription.)
CRIS In-house Services
In-house searches of the CRIS database, prepared by CRIS staff, are provided at no charge to research scientists and managers at CRIS participating institutions. Requests from counterparts in other federal and state agencies, local governments, and educational institutions are honored as time and resources permit. Requests from private organizations and the public are referred to commercial search services.
Requesting Service
USDA and state users who want to request a CRIS search should complete Form AD- 427. Others may submit requests, preferably by letter, specifying:
| User name, mailing address, and telephone number. | |
| Date information is needed. | |
| Topic or subject area to be searched (within 100 words). | |
| Purpose of the request. | |
| USDA and state users may submit requests on Form AD-427 via e-mail on FTS2000MAIL or on the Internet. |
Requesting CRIS Searches
Send your request to:
Current Research Information System
Science and Education Resources Development
Cooperative State Research, Education, and Extension Service
USDA, National Agricultural Library Bldg, 5th Floor
Beltsville, MD 20705-2351
(301) 504-6272
INTERNET:cris@cris.nal.usda.gov
Open the CRIS Forms Assistance homepage located at http://ctr.uvm.edu/cris/. You can bookmark this homepage, but no subsequent pages can be bookmarked.
| Select Using CRIS Web Forms from the
homepage. Select AD-416 Research Resume from the "Enter CRIS Web Forms...." section. |
**Note the version of your browser. Obtain a newer browser if needed before proceeding.
Select: IDA - Agricultural Experiment Station, Univ of Idaho
Enter " bear " as the password and then click the [Proceed] button.
Enter your last name and [Display] the work list of projects for you as the
principal investigator. Select one project on the worklist and select "AD-416
Research Resume" and [Proceed]
-- OR -- If you are initiating a new AD-416, select one of the following:
| "New Formula Funded or State Project" | |
| "New Grant/Coop Agreement" ****NOTE: the funding source determines which type of AD-416 you initiate | |
| "Revised AD-416 for an existing project not currently in the work list" |
[Proceed] and enter the following information:
Project Number
When entering a new AD-416, if you are not normally the one to assign this number,
leave it blank.
Status
A = NEW Projects submitted for approval.
C = REVISED Projects already documented in CRIS that are being revised.
Regional Project Number
The regional project number identifies projects supported by Regional Research funds, or
those formally on record as contributing to a Regional Research project. This number
combines the region (NE, NC, S, IR, or W) and the project number in the format region-###
(for example, NE-999).
Funding Type
Select only one CSREES funding program, or "S = State" which can be used for any
other funding sources.
Title
Enter the title for this project. Titles are limited to 100 characters, including spaces.
Do not use phrases such as "research on " "investigation of," etc.
Quotation marks, question mark, and underscoring are not acceptable. NOTE: Regional
Research title must be entered exactly as approved by the Committee of Nine.
Performing/Cooperating Departments
Select the home department of the Principal Investigator for the Performing Department,
and select up to 2 departments participating significantly in the project.
Investigator Names
A total of six can be listed. List the Principal Investigator on Line 1. Lines 2 through
six are used for co-investigators.
Objectives
Enter a clear, concise statement of the objectives of the research, which should be
specific and attainable within the duration of the project using the resources available.
Not to exceed 1440 characters. **
Approach
Describe the ways in which the research is to be conducted, with emphasis on the
scientific methods and any unique aspects or significant departures from usual approaches.
Not to exceed 1440 characters. **
** We recommend that you paste in the text from your wordprocessor (spell-check here), but
do not include formatting such as tab, indent, bold, underline, super/subscript,
nor any graphic symbols.
Keywords
Enter one per line in the entry field. Not to exceed 29 characters per keyword and
345 characters total. It is important to assign appropriate keywords for automated
information retrieval of project information. Generally, keywords should be limited to
one- or two-word terms. Collectively, the keywords for a project should resemble an
abbreviated abstract of the project. Ideally, choose at least 12 keywords that describe
the nature of the study at 3 levels: (1) general entry, overall objectives in the major
fields of interest (select at least 2), (2) class entry, classes or categories of subjects
or items, and moderately broad concepts or areas of interest which conceptually group the
specific entry keyword into like classes (select at least 4), (3) specific entry, the most
specific concepts, subjects or items under study, including the specific plant, animal, or
microorganism; the specific equipment, processes, approach, technique or system; and
specific properties, reaction, or function (select at least 6).
Start Date
Enter date research will begin as Month, Day, Year in numeric format, (e.g. 07/01/1998).
Termination Date
Enter the estimated termination date for the project as Month, Day, Year in numeric
format, (e.g. 06/30/2003).
Contract Number
When all information is entered, [Check Data] and note any errors. View the displayed information carefully. Corrections or additional edits can be made by using the [BACK] button on your browser toolbar. After each edit, [Check Data] again.
When the information is correct and complete, [Save Information]. You should see a Confirmation Screen if your information was successfully saved in the work file. You may want to print a copy of this page to keep for your records.
II. CRIS Web Forms - AD-417 Instructions
The AD-417 Classification process on the web forms is confusing to some users. The AD-417 form simply is NOT intuitive. Below are some suggestions that might be helpful. AD-417 instructions have not been developed and posted on the web because the classification system is currently being reviewed and will be changing dramatically, possibly as soon as December, 1998. The new classification system will be simplified and all possible combinations will be allowed. Projects submitted now still need to be classified using the guidelines as listed in the CRIS Manual <http://ctr.uvm.edu/cris/crisman/m_417.htm> that is available on the web.
Some suggestions for completing the AD-417 web forms:
| Using an AD-417 worksheet: Print an AD-417 blank worksheet. <http://ctr.uvm.edu/cris/blanks/blank417.htm> Note the font options <http://ctr.uvm.edu/cris/htmforms.htm> to set in your browser to print forms on one page. |
| Enter the CRIS Web Forms "AD-417 Classification," selecting a project and the "AD-417 Classification" form to work on. Enter the percentages for "Research Effort Category" (effort must total 100%). Help links define the categories and links are available to the online CRIS Manuals. |
| Enter the Primary Classification. |
| The Research Program Area (RPA) link displays the 9 agricultural goals and the RPAs that
are available per goal. Select a goal(s) and find a RPA or several that best defines the
research project. Write these RPA codes on your worksheet. |
| Select one of the RPAs from your worksheet and a link for the activities and commodities
allowable for that RPA will be listed from each in the web forms. |
| Open the "activities for this RPA" and "commodities for this RPA"
links, writing down the code number for each respectively on your worksheet that best
describes the focus of the project. |
| Use your browser BACK button to the Primary classification WebPage. Follow the
"Science" link, again selecting the field of science that best describes the
project and write this code on your worksheet. |
| Again, use your BACK button to the Primary classification WebPage. Enter the full line
of classification codes from your worksheet into the web forms for each corresponding
field and assign the % of effort per line of classification. |
| Do not assign less than 10% per line and the total must equal 100. When the primary
line(s) of classification is complete, proceed with the "data checking." The
data checking process will alert you if any "Subcommodities" or "Special
classification" codes are needed or if you have entered a combination that is not
allowed. |
| To display the subcommodities or special classification choices, select the links, again
noting the codes on your worksheet if needed. Use your BACK button to the primary
classification page, enter the codes into the web forms and proceed with the "data
checking" again to check for any errors. |
| When you have completed the classification and the data checking process, be sure to
"save" your work. |
| You can edit any of the forms from your AD-416/417/662 admin function "display/edit/delete forms." When all forms are completed you need to select the "mark ready" button before you can submit to CRIS. |
III. CRIS Web Forms - AD-421 Instructions
Your research report is entered into the CRIS (Current Research Information System) database where it is available to fellow research scientists and administrators on a nationwide basis, and to the public worldwide in the CRISTEL online file http://cristel.nal.usda.gov:8080.
You will be entering these data from the CRIS Forms Assistance WebPages. To access these pages, use your Web browser. Netscape 2.02 or higher and MS Internet Explorer 3.0 and higher have been tested successfully.
Open the CRIS Forms Assistance homepage located at http://ctr.uvm.edu/cris.
Select Using CRIS Web Forms from the homepage.
Select the AD-421 Progress/Termination Report from the "Enter CRIS Web Forms...." section.
**Note the version of your browser. Obtain a newer browser if needed before proceeding.
Select: IDA - Agricultural Experiment Station, Univ of Idaho
Enter " bear " as the password and then Proceed.
Enter your name to display the list of projects that require reports from you as the principal investigator.
Select one project from the list and Proceed.
Enter the following information:
1) Choose the appropriate report, either:
Progress: If the termination date has not passed and the project was active during
the current reporting year
Termination: Only if the termination date has passed and the project will not
be extended beyond this listed date
2
) Progress/Termination narrative:3) Publications:
Example:
When all information is entered, select Check Data and note any errors. View the displayed information carefully. Corrections or additional edits can be made by using the BACK button on your browser toolbar. After each edit, Check Data again.
When the information is correct and complete, select Save Report. You should see a Confirmation Screen if your report was successfully saved in the site's collection file. You may also want to print a copy of this page to keep for your records and or submit for review.
When you are completely finished with the report and do not need to edit it further, select the Report Complete button. Once you select this button, you will not be able to edit the report again, and it will then be submitted to CRIS for you. You MUST "press" this button to indicate when the report is complete. Your report cannot be submitted to CRIS until you mark it complete. and it can then be submitted to CRIS.
If you have more than 1 project, use the BACK button of your browser until reaching the Project Selection page. Use your browser's Reload button to see checkmarks by completed reports. Select another project and follow the same steps as outlined previously. Submit a report for ALL projects that are listed for you.
IV. CRIS Web Forms CSREES-662 Assurance Statement Instructions
This form is submitted at a project's inception or revision along with the AD-416/417. The assurance statement is required as policy for safeguarding the rights and welfare of human and animal subjects used in investigations.
|
|